See also link to submitted themes and physics opportunities within the DPWG. Refer to the meeting from Nov 15.
The DPWG discussion focused on identifying the major scientific questions and future physics opportunities for CEBAF/CLAS12 over the next decade and beyond in connection with possible hardware targets. The aim was to consider new directions while making clear connections to the existing physics program and the capabilities needed to pursue these opportunities, and summarize the main scientific themes unique for CEBAF.
The short presentations were intended to introduce broader scientific themes and stimulate discussion, rather than provide an exhaustive review or establish a ranking of physics priorities.
Volker - Color confinement and GPDs
Volker discussed the opportunity to investigate color confinement through measurements of the nucleon's internal structure and force distributions. The proposed program builds on existing DVCS and TCS measurements, with future opportunities involving DDVCS, GPDs, and gravitational form factors. Particular attention was given to the importance of extending the kinematic coverage and experimental capabilities needed to probe the internal force distributions.
Rafayel - Physics opportunities with muCLAS12
Rafayel presented the future physics opportunities enabled by muCLAS12 and mini-muCLAS12. These include DDVCS measurements to extend our access to GPDs, as well as near-threshold (J/\psi) production to investigate gluonic structure in nucleons and nuclei. The discussion highlighted the connection between these scientific opportunities and the proposed detector upgrades, including improved muon detection and higher-luminosity capabilities.
Harut - Future opportunities in SIDIS and exclusive processes
Harut discussed opportunities to advance our understanding of nonperturbative QCD through exclusive and semi-inclusive hadron production. Topics included the separation of longitudinal and transverse photon contributions, extraction of helicity structure functions and amplitudes, higher-twist effects, and correlations between hadrons in the current and target fragmentation regions. These measurements also provide opportunities to improve the interpretation of SIDIS observables and connect the CEBAF and EIC physics programs.
Discussion
GPDs, polarized targets, and neutron measurements
Silvia emphasized that, while the proton GPD (H) is already relatively well constrained, important parts of the GPD program remain largely unexplored, particularly GPD (E) and neutron GPD measurements. Neutron DVCS, flavor separation, and measurements with polarized proton and neutron-sensitive targets are essential for developing a more complete understanding of nucleon structure.
It was agreed that the GPD physics case should be strengthened with a couple of additional slides highlighting future opportunities with polarized and neutron-rich targets, and their importance for the broader scientific goals.
Connecting scientific questions to experimental opportunities
The discussion emphasized the need to communicate the broader physics motivation clearly, especially when presenting the future program to laboratory management and the wider community.
For SIDIS, this includes fundamental questions about three-dimensional nucleon structure, spin–momentum correlations, and the unique opportunities provided by polarized beams and targets at CEBAF. The message should focus on why these measurements matter for understanding QCD, rather than primarily on individual observables or technical developments.
Theory, phenomenology, and experiment
The importance of bringing theorists, phenomenologists, and experimentalists together was emphasized. Progress in interpreting precision measurements, particularly in the transition between different reaction mechanisms and kinematic regimes, requires close interaction between these communities.
Limits of theoretical descriptions and transitions between kinematic regimes
Richard raised broader scientific questions concerning the limits of applicability of factorization frameworks and our understanding of the transition between the resonance and deep-process regions.
These questions provide connections between the SIDIS and exclusive physics programs and could be important directions for future CEBAF studies.
Additional contributions and follow-up
- High-(x) physics: Sebastian Kuhn was unable to present his contribution on PDFs and spin structure at very high (x). We will try to incorporate this physics direction into the High-Luminosity Workshop discussions during the Collaboration Meeting on Thursday.
- GPD physics case: Add material emphasizing polarized targets, neutron measurements, GPD (E), and flavor separation.
- Broader community discussion: Continue developing the connections between the existing approved program, new scientific opportunities, and the experimental and theoretical capabilities needed to pursue them.
Some conclusions
The discussion highlighted several connected scientific directions: understanding confinement and the internal structure of hadrons, extending access to quark and gluon structure through new measurements, and investigating nonperturbative QCD through SIDIS and exclusive processes.
The importance of presenting a clear, high-level scientific vision, building on the existing CEBAF/CLAS12 program, and strengthening connections between experiment and theory was emphasized.